I love bananas. I am bananas for bananas. Sorry, I had to do it.

So I was very excited to make the week’s Tuesdays with Dorie, which was Banana Cream Pie chosen by Amy of Sing for Your Supper. Amy has a fabulous blog that you should definitely take a few minutes to peruse. This was my first banana cream pie and it was totally delicious. Great pick Amy! This recipe is on page 342-43 of Baking: From My Home to Yours by Dorie Greenspan.
Image from Amazon

Follow up:

I decided to make this pie in stages since I had some time issues this week. I made the pastry cream first, which I completed with no incident. It is a standard pastry cream flavored with brown sugar, cinnamon, and nutmeg. Yum!

Then I set out to make the dough. I opted not to use Dorie’s Good for Almost Everything Pie Dough. I have made it before and I prefer an all butter crust with my pie, or to be more accurate, I prefer crusts without shortening. I do have a go to shortening free crust, courtesy of Joe Pastry (and Rose Levy Berenbaum). Unfortunately, this crust requires more time than I had available. So I picked a simple pâte brisée from Simply Recipes. That did not work out well. So I made a last minute Nilla Wafer crust, like a graham cracker crust, but with Nilla Wafers. Delicious! As well as easier and cheaper. I would have saved myself alot of time and butter if I had thought of that first. It also reminded me how much I like Nilla Wafers.

I also made the whipped cream topping a few hours ahead. I was worried about it deflating, so I stabilized it with some gelatin and it worked beautifully. I had never done that before, but will definitely remember this nifty trick in the future.

This pie was easy to assemble and after a quick chill in the fridge I served it to a bunch of beer drinking men who were watching the 25th anniversary of Wrestlemania on PPV. (side note - have you ever watched this WWE stuff? It is out of control funny and ridiculous. I never knew!) Everyone seemed to really like the pie. I think this recipe is a keeper, and the crunchy Nilla Wafer crust with the creamy bananas was superb.

I was in a rush to get these pictures before my light was gone for the day, so these are not top quality, but they’ll do.